Navigating the Minefield of Scammers in Your First Month of Online Selling

Cartoon of lady frustrated by scammers

Starting an online selling journey can be exciting and full of promise. Yet, the first month often reveals a harsh reality: scammers are everywhere, ready to take advantage of new sellers. This post shares practical insights and real experiences to help you spot scams early, protect your business, and build confidence as you grow.

My Experience with Etsy and Poshmark

• Fake Etsy Purchases

As soon as you post your first item for sale on Etsy, you will get an email saying a purchase has been made. This can be exciting to think you made a sale so fast. However, it's probably a fake with a link to get your information. Check the Etsy website to confirm ANY communication . Also check their website for information on their legitimate email addresses.

• Messages Asking To Buy

The first week I got a message asking to purchase an item from my website images. I told the person I would post it in Etsy, where they can make the purchase. I posted the item for sales and let them know. They said Etsy wouldn't take their card and asked if I used Venmo. This is a tale-tale signal that this is a scam. I immediately deleted the conversation. Never allow purchases outside of the selling platform.

• Fake Poshmark Messages

The first week or two, you will get messages on your Poshmark feed saying you need to verify your information. These are all fake. If you have followed the process to setup your Posh closet, you will not need to verify your information. Do not click on any of those messages.

---

Recognizing Common Scams in Online Selling

New sellers often face several types of scams. Knowing what to watch for can save you time, money, and stress.

• Fake Payment Confirmations

Scammers may send fake emails or messages claiming payment has been made. They often ask you to ship the item before the payment clears. Always verify payments through your selling platform or bank before shipping.

• Overpayment Scams

A buyer sends a payment exceeding the item price and asks for a refund of the difference. The original payment later bounces or is reversed, leaving you out of pocket.

• Phishing Attempts

Scammers try to steal your login details by sending fake emails that look like they come from your selling platform. Never click on suspicious links or provide your password outside official sites.

• Fake Buyer Profiles

Some scammers create profiles with stolen photos and fake reviews to appear trustworthy. Look for inconsistencies in buyer behavior or unusual requests.

Practical Steps to Protect Yourself

Taking precautions early can reduce your risk of falling victim to scams.

• Use Trusted Platforms

Sell through well-known marketplaces that offer seller protection and secure payment systems.

• Verify Payments Before Shipping

Check your account balance directly on your bank or platform, not just email notifications.

• Set Clear Policies

Outline your return, refund, and shipping policies clearly. This helps avoid confusion and gives you a reference if disputes arise.

• Communicate Through Official Channels

Keep all buyer communication on the platform to have a record in case of issues.

• Trust Your Instincts

If a deal feels too good to be true or a buyer is pushing for unusual terms, pause and investigate.

Close-up of suspicious phishing email on smartphone screen

Real Experiences from the First Month

Many new sellers share stories that highlight common pitfalls.

One seller received a message from a buyer claiming to have paid twice by mistake and asked for a refund of the extra amount. The seller sent the refund quickly, only to find the original payment never arrived. This scam cost them hundreds of dollars.

Another seller was contacted by a buyer who insisted on communicating outside the platform and pressured for quick shipping. The seller ignored the request and reported the buyer. The platform removed the suspicious account, preventing further scams.

These examples show the importance of patience and verification. Rushing to please buyers can lead to costly mistakes.

Handling Suspicious Situations

If you suspect a scam, take these steps:

• Pause All Transactions

Stop shipping or refunding until you confirm payment and buyer identity.

• Report to the Platform

Most marketplaces have dedicated teams to handle fraud. Reporting helps protect you and others.

• Document Everything

Keep records of messages, payment confirmations, and transactions.

• Seek Advice

Join seller forums or groups where experienced sellers share tips and warnings.

Seller reviewing transaction records and buyer messages on laptop

Building Confidence Beyond the First Month

Once you navigate the initial challenges, you can focus on growing your business with more confidence.

• Learn from Each Experience

Every scam attempt teaches you what to watch for next time.

• Build a Trusted Buyer Base

Repeat customers and positive reviews reduce the chance of scams.

• Stay Updated

Scammers change tactics. Keep informed about new scams through seller communities and platform updates.

• Use Secure Payment Methods

Consider payment options that offer buyer and seller protection.

Starting online selling is a learning process. Scammers are part of the landscape, but with vigilance and smart practices, you can protect your business and thrive.